ARCA Supply Cuts Costs and Accelerates Growth with BigCommerce

See how customisable, cost-effective and reliable BigCommerce is and why we built it that way.

Laptop screen showing ARCA website with electrical surplus items, yellow banner, and shop now button.

75%

reduction in platform development costs

2X

YOY growth acceleration

20+

hours weekly time savings in manual processes

Modernising the electrical supply chain

Asset Recovery Company of America (ARCA) Supply took a different approach to surplus liquidation, one built on transparency, relationships, and smart technology choices. What began as a garage startup in Buffalo has grown into a thriving B2B distribution business, fueled by a well-timed investment in the right ecommerce platform.

As part of the Circular Economy Group, ARCA specialises in acquiring and reselling surplus electrical power distribution equipment. Unlike traditional liquidators, they operate within established industry frameworks and work directly with manufacturers and distributors. They’re also active members of IMARK and AD buying groups, adding credibility and deepening ties within the electrical distributor community.

Their BigCommerce site became the foundation of that strategy, giving them the flexibility to scale while reinforcing the transparency and professionalism that set them apart.

CHALLENGE

Escaping a custom development nightmare.

When ARCA Supply first needed an ecommerce platform, they made the mistake many growing companies make: they hired a custom development firm to build everything from scratch. What started as a $30,000 project with a three-month timeline quickly spiraled into a costly nightmare.

The custom development project changed hands multiple times within the agency. Basic functionality was missing, product pages were stark, and the website's layout was difficult to navigate. Even worse, the lack of control meant ARCA couldn't make simple changes like updating product attributes or category names without going through the development company.

After months of delays and mounting costs, David Marak, Director of Sales at ARCA, realised they were a third of the way to a functional website that would likely cost another $50,000 to complete, plus require a full-time developer to maintain.

The company needed a solution that would give them control over their catalog, streamline B2B operations, and integrate with their existing systems without breaking the bank.

"I couldn't go in and move something, or add a product attribute, or change a category name. I had to ask them to do everything. And when I started asking them why all these changes were so difficult, they said, 'Oh well, you guys were a special case and we custom-built everything for you,'" shared David.

"I couldn't go in and move something, or add a product attribute, or change a category name. I had to ask them to do everything. And when I started asking them why all these changes were so difficult, they said, 'Oh well, you guys were a special case and we custom-built everything for you.'"

DAVID MARAK, DIRECTOR OF SALES, ARCA

SOLUTION

Simpler setup and stronger results.

David's frustration with the custom development approach led him to test several ecommerce platforms during a weekend trial period. With BigCommerce, he accomplished more in two days than months of custom development had delivered. He connected their ERP system via API, pushed products through, processed test orders, and configured product pages and categories.

The contrast was stark. When David showed the development company what he'd built on BigCommerce's trial platform, they fell silent. The platform's out-of-the-box functionality eliminated the need for custom development while providing superior results.

Platform stability has been remarkable since the migration. The team rarely receives calls about site downtime or broken functionality. BigCommerce's automatic status notifications and responsive support team handle issues quickly when they do arise.

"We wouldn't be able to support the systems that we're supporting if BigCommerce wasn't as it was. We've definitely had to go in and tweak things here or there. But I can't remember the last time that I got a phone call that was, ‘the site went down’, or ‘this broke’, or ‘this product page doesn't load,'" remarked David.

Streamlined integration with existing systems.

BigCommerce’s open architecture made it easy for ARCA to integrate with Sellercloud, their existing omnichannel and order management system. With built-in compatibility and simple API key entry, ARCA quickly synced product data, pricing, and inventory, with no custom development required.

This seamless integration became the backbone of their operations. Sales teams could now rely on BigCommerce as the central catalog, with real-time data consistency across every connected system. In fact, BigCommerce soon outperformed ARCA’s ERP for customer-facing use, giving reps a faster, more reliable way to guide customers through the sales process.

“We've leaned more heavily on BigCommerce to be the catalog for the sales team. I’ve even started enforcing that the sales team put all orders through the website rather than directly into the ERP, because that way it creates consistency on the customer side,” said David. “All orders are in the same place. They’re getting notifications through the same formatting. It’s been really, really helpful.”

ARCA now saves approximately 20 hours per week by eliminating manual Excel imports, data entry, and customer notifications, freeing up the team to focus on faster order processing, consistent follow-up, and a better end-to-end experience for every buyer.

Strong B2B features out-of-the-box.

When evaluating platforms, David quickly saw that BigCommerce wasn’t just keeping up with B2B, it was leading. While Shopify was rolling out similar features, it consistently trailed BigCommerce’s B2B roadmap by months.

BigCommerce’s dedicated investment in B2B functionality aligned directly with ARCA’s distributor-first strategy. Features like customer portals, company accounts, tiered pricing, personalised catalogs, and simplified order management weren’t add-ons, they were ready to go out of the box, purpose-built for the way B2B businesses operate.

ARCA now uses these tools to manage complex buyer relationships, streamline reorders, and deliver a tailored experience to every customer. These capabilities also dramatically improved back-office efficiency, order processing time was cut in half, and their customer service manager saved roughly 20 hours per week by eliminating manual data entry and customer notification tasks.

“I like the customisation of the customer portal, where you can change how things look and add your own logo,” shared David. “Our customers like it because they can go to one spot, get all the information they need, and our sales team can walk them through the experience from the back end.”

“We've leaned more heavily on BigCommerce to be the catalog for the sales team. I’ve even started enforcing that the sales team put all orders through the website rather than directly into the ERP, because that way it creates consistency on the customer side.”

DAVID MARAK, DIRECTOR OF SALES, ARCA

"We wouldn't be able to support the systems that we're supporting if BigCommerce wasn't as it was. We've definitely had to go in and tweak things here or there. But I can't remember the last time that I got a phone call that was, ‘the site went down’, or ‘this broke’, or ‘this product page doesn't load’."

DAVID MARAK, DIRECTOR OF SALES, ARCA

Tablet displaying an online store for electrical parts, showing product images, prices, and filter options on the left.

RESULTS

Built to scale without the overhead.

Switching to BigCommerce eliminated more than $50,000 in anticipated custom development costs and removed the need for a full-time developer, saving at least one annual salary.

ARCA has sustained nearly 2x year-over-year growth for several years. With BigCommerce in place, technology is no longer a barrier to scale. Resources once tied up in platform maintenance are now focused on business development and growth.

The migration also resolved previous concerns around security and compliance. With enterprise-grade protections including ISO and PCI compliance, ARCA avoided the cost and complexity of managing data security in-house.

“The website isn't a barrier to actually wanting to execute strategy and business decisions, so that's definitely helpful,” shared Jeff Orlowski, Ecommerce Marketing Manager at ARCA.

“The website isn't a barrier to actually wanting to execute strategy and business decisions, so that's definitely helpful.”

JEFF ORLOWSKI, ECOMMERCE MARKETING MANAGER, ARCA

LOOKING AHEAD

Positioned for what comes next.

ARCA Supply is continuing to expand its multi-channel strategy, using BigCommerce’s flexible APIs to connect with new partners and distribution channels. They’re actively exploring EDI integration and evaluating Multi-Storefront to better separate their B2B and surplus liquidation operations.

As they transition to a more robust ERP system, ARCA remains confident that BigCommerce’s integration capabilities will support a seamless shift. Their focus is on scaling liquidation operations, deepening OEM relationships, and exploring dropshipping as a growth channel.

“In the near future, we’re going to continue making strong use of API connections and the customisations we’ve built. We’re also building stronger OEM relationships and moving toward authorised brand representation in key categories,” said David.

With BigCommerce’s ongoing investment in B2B functionality, ARCA’s ecommerce strategy remains aligned with the platform’s roadmap, gaining access to new features that continue to strengthen operational efficiency.

“In the near future, we’re going to continue making strong use of API connections and the customisations we’ve built. We’re also building stronger OEM relationships and moving toward authorised brand representation in key categories.”

DAVID MARAK, DIRECTOR OF SALES, ARCA

More Stories of Success

Read Case Study

Marshall Wolf Automation

Read Their Story
Read Case StudyA hand operates a metal key-cutting machine, pressing the handle down to cut a key blank on a workbench.

TradeTools

Read Their Story
Read Case Study

Toolden

Read Their Story